15 min read · 2,831 words
“Do we have enough stamps?” my cousin Jo asked, licking the flap of the last envelope at my kitchen table.
That was the last plain thing she said before she crossed her name off the reunion list.
I had a stack of invitations between us and the old address book my mother used to keep. It still had phone numbers written in blue ink from the years before everybody got cell phones. Jo was helping because I’d been doing the reunion for six years, and she’s the kind of person who notices when the labels are crooked.
I thought we were having an ordinary afternoon.
Jo had been with Lena for eleven years. I knew that. I’d eaten dinner at their house, called Lena when Jo had surgery, and sent them both a Christmas card every year. Still, I’d addressed the invitation to “Jo and guest.”
I told myself it was polite. I told myself I was avoiding a family argument before it started.
Jo put down the envelope. “Why does Lena not have a name?”
I said I’d been in a hurry. That was true, but not the whole truth.
I could see her looking at the envelope, then at me. She didn’t raise her voice. That made it worse.
“I’m not asking you to fight with anybody,” she said. “I’m asking you to invite my partner like she belongs there.”
I started to say that of course Lena belonged there. But my mouth got ahead of me, like it usually does when I’m embarrassed. I said the reunion was for everybody and I didn’t want Uncle Ray turning it into a whole thing.
Jo picked up the pen.
“Then I guess I’m not coming.”
She crossed her name off the list. Not hard. Just one straight line through it.
I watched her do it and still tried to make it sound like a misunderstanding. That is one of my worse habits. I start managing other people’s feelings before I’ve admitted what I did.
Jo took her coat from the back of the chair. She didn’t slam the door. She just left the invitation on the table.
The envelope had “and guest” written in my handwriting.
I called her after supper and apologized. I told her I’d make a new invitation with Lena’s name on it. Jo said she appreciated that, but she wasn’t ready to say yes.
Then she asked me what I would do when Uncle Ray objected.
I said I’d handle it.
She waited a second. “What does that mean?”
I didn’t have an answer. I heard myself say I’d call her back.
That night, I sat at the kitchen table with the invitation and felt worse than I expected to. Not because Jo had yelled at me. She hadn’t. I felt bad because she’d asked one simple thing, and I’d made it sound like a problem she was bringing into the family.
I’d been doing that for years, only in smaller ways.
At Christmas, I’d asked Jo if Lena was coming, instead of saying I’d saved a seat for Lena. When we made plans at my mother’s house, I’d sometimes call Jo and say, “Bring whoever you want,” like Lena was an extra place setting she could decide to use. I had never said anything nasty to Lena. I thought that counted for more than it did.
I guess I’d treated politeness as a substitute for welcome.
The reunion was in May at the county community hall, the same place we’d used since I took over from my mother. The room had a kitchen with a coffee pot that always tasted faintly like the hot plate. We’d bring fried chicken, potato salad, sheet cake, and a box of family photos somebody would eventually pass around.
It wasn’t fancy. That was part of why I liked it. Nobody needed to dress up, and the kids could run between the tables without anyone worrying about the carpet.
Ray had come every year since I’d been organizing it. He was my mother’s older brother, and he liked to be asked before people changed anything. He also thought that because he was older, his opinion had already been considered.
When I was younger, he was the uncle who took us fishing and let us sit in the front seat of his truck. I didn’t want to turn him into a bad man in my head. I still don’t. But I knew what he thought about Jo and Lena. He’d made his opinion clear in little remarks, never long enough to sound like a speech.
After Jo came out, Ray had said, “I don’t want to hear about it at the table.”
My mother changed the subject. I did too.
That’s the part I keep coming back to. I didn’t want a fight, so I let Jo carry the strain of keeping the peace. Then I called myself kind because I hadn’t picked a side.
I rewrote the envelope the next morning. I put “Jo and Lena” on the front in black ink. I didn’t write “and guest.” I took a picture and texted it to Jo.
She didn’t respond for a few hours. I kept checking my phone, which was ridiculous. I was the one who’d made the mess.
Finally she wrote, “That’s better. I’m still thinking.”
I wanted to ask what there was to think about. I didn’t. I knew.
A week later I went to Jo and Lena’s for coffee. I’d brought the invitation, though it was already in the mail. I also brought a grocery-store pound cake because my mother taught me never to show up empty-handed, even when cake was not the point.
Lena answered the door. She gave me a quick hug and moved aside. Jo was in the kitchen putting mugs on the table.
I remember that one mug had a small chip near the handle. I don’t know why I remember it. Maybe because I held it too carefully.
“I’m sorry,” I said.
Jo stirred her coffee. “For the envelope?”
“For the envelope. For making you feel like you had to explain Lena. For knowing Ray would be difficult and acting like that was your problem to solve.”
Lena looked at me but didn’t say anything.
I said I’d put both their names on the invitation. I said I’d also make sure there was a place for them at the table.
Jo said, “That’s not the same as answering me.”
She was right. I had come to bring an apology, hoping the apology would do the rest.
I told her I hadn’t spoken to Ray yet.
“Are you going to?”
I said I was.
“What are you going to say?”
I took a sip of coffee and burned my tongue. I had not thought beyond telling him that Lena was invited. I was still treating the hard part like a conversation I could schedule and control.
“I’ll tell him she’s part of the family,” I said.
Jo’s face didn’t change. “You already know he won’t agree.”
I said I knew.
That was the whole reason I’d left her name off in the first place. I didn’t want Ray to object, and I didn’t want Jo to see me trying to keep him comfortable at her expense. Somehow I’d thought I could have both.
Lena spoke then. “I don’t need him to like me.”
She said it quietly. No drama. She was holding the spoon in both hands, rolling it between her fingers.
“I just don’t want to be introduced like I’m somebody Jo brought along.”
I said I understood. I don’t know if I did right then. I understood the words. I hadn’t felt how often I’d put her in that position.
Jo walked me to the door. She thanked me for coming over, which was kind of her and also made me feel like a person who’d needed to be thanked for doing the minimum.
When I got home, Ray’s invitation was still on the counter. I had written “Ray and Martha” on it. Martha had died four years earlier, but I still thought of the two of them together when I addressed mail. I changed it to “Ray.”
I did that, then sat there with the pen in my hand.
I called him after dinner. He was watching the evening news and had to turn down the television.
I told him the invitation was in the mail. I said Jo and Lena were coming, if they decided to, and they’d be listed by name.
He was quiet long enough that I could hear the TV from his end.
Then he said, “I’m not sitting at a table with that.”
I felt my face get hot. I was standing by the sink with a dish towel in my hand. It had a little hole near the corner, and I started pulling at it.
I said I wasn’t asking him to approve of anyone. I said Lena was Jo’s partner and she was invited.
Ray said, “You’re making this into something.”
I almost backed down. I want to be honest about that. I said maybe we could talk about it at the reunion, which would have meant Jo and Lena walking into the room without knowing whether they were welcome.
Ray said he’d think about coming.
I thanked him. I actually thanked him.
Then I hung up and felt ashamed of how quickly I’d given him room to decide whether two people could sit at the same table.
The next few days, I kept finding reasons not to call Jo. I wanted to tell her what Ray had said, but I didn’t want to make her carry the news before I knew what I was going to do. That sounds considerate. It was mostly fear. I was afraid she’d ask me to make a choice, and I was afraid I already knew the answer.
My mother called to ask whether Ray had received his invitation. She said she hoped I hadn’t “stirred things up” over the reunion.
I told her I’d invited Lena by name.
There was a pause.
“You know how Ray is,” she said.
I said I did.
“He’s old-fashioned.”
I started to say that old-fashioned wasn’t the same as harmless. Instead, I asked if she was coming.
“Of course,” she said. “I’m not missing my own family reunion.”
I wanted to ask if Jo was her family too. I didn’t. I hung up and put the kettle on, even though I didn’t want tea.
This was the part where I could have kept it vague and hoped the day went smoothly. I could tell Jo that Ray might be there and let her choose whether to risk it. I could also say I’d done my best, which is a phrase people use when they’d rather be done.
I sent Jo a text. I told her Ray had objected and I hadn’t answered him well. I asked if she would talk to me.
She called that night.
I told her I was sorry I’d made her ask twice. I said I’d call Ray again, and this time I’d tell him what would happen if he refused to sit with Lena.
Jo was quiet. “What would happen?”
I swallowed. “He’d have to leave.”
I heard a little breath from her end. Not relief, exactly.
“Are you sure you can do that?”
I said yes.
That was the first time I believed myself.
I called Ray the next day. He answered while he was out in his garage, and there was a radio playing low in the background. I told him Jo and Lena were coming, and I needed him to understand they were invited as a couple.
He said, “I told you how I feel.”
“I know. But you don’t get to make Lena leave.”
“I’m not making anybody do anything.”
“You said you wouldn’t sit with her.”
“I said what I said.”
I stood there rubbing the side of my thumb. I wanted him to give me an easy way out. I wanted him to say he’d just been mad, or he’d changed his mind, or he’d come and behave. Instead he said he’d decide for himself whether to come.
I said he could decide. I also said if he came and made Jo or Lena feel unwelcome, I’d ask him to leave.
He let out a short laugh. “You’d throw your own uncle out?”
I looked at the old address book on the counter. My mother’s blue ink was faded at the edges. I’d used it to keep track of everybody, like being the person with the list meant I was keeping the family together.
“Yes,” I said.
He hung up.
I didn’t feel brave. I felt sick and a little angry that I’d let one phone call turn into a test I had to pass. Still, I had finally answered Jo’s question.
Ray didn’t call back. For a few days, I figured he wasn’t coming.
Jo texted me to say she and Lena would come, but she wanted to drive separately. I said that was fine. I didn’t ask her to reassure me.
The morning of the reunion, I got there early to put out the name cards. I’d written Jo and Lena on two cards, side by side. I put them near the middle of the table, not off at the end by the kitchen.
I had a folding chair in one hand when Ray walked in.
He was carrying a dish of deviled eggs. He’d made them himself, which I knew because he always put paprika on some and left the rest plain. He set the dish down and looked at the name cards.
“Where do you want these?” he asked.
I told him there was room on the table by the drinks.
He glanced at Jo and Lena’s cards. He didn’t say anything right away. I could see him deciding whether to start the argument in front of the people who were already arriving.
Jo and Lena came in a few minutes later. Jo gave me a quick hug. Lena said the room smelled like coffee, and I told her it always did. I was glad she said something ordinary. It gave me a second to breathe.
Ray was near the drinks. Jo saw him, then looked at me.
I walked over before I could talk myself out of it. I told Ray the food table was full, so I’d set his eggs on the side counter. I said Jo and Lena were here, and I expected him to speak to them respectfully.
He said, “I’m not doing anything.”
“Okay,” I said. “Then we won’t have a problem.”
I don’t know why that sentence came out of me. It was plain and maybe a little stiff. But I meant it.
Ray went to sit with my mother and two of his cousins. Nobody made a speech. Nobody clapped. People started eating. The reunion kept being a reunion, with paper plates and kids asking where the cookies were.
Ray didn’t sit with Jo and Lena. They didn’t ask him to. He also didn’t make a scene or say anything cruel. He left after about an hour, taking the empty egg dish with him.
Jo and Lena stayed until the cake was cut.
When I was stacking chairs, Jo came over and helped me carry one to the closet. She said, “Thanks for not making me handle him.”
I said I should have done it before.
She didn’t say it was all forgiven. I didn’t ask her to.
I’m glad I finally kept my word. I’m also embarrassed it took a marked-out name on an envelope to show me what I’d been asking her to put up with. The next year, when I pulled out the address book, I wrote Lena’s name beside Jo’s before I addressed the first invitation.